top of page

Island Restaurants

OTW rainbow.jpg

Small Title

Over The Water

Superb food, great family dining

In our opinion, this is the best restaurant on the island! Chef Dave always has great options on the menu for lunch and dinner.  Check with your Home Manager for the weekly open schedule during your stay or call 239-472-4762.


There is indoor and deck seating so you can watch dolphins play in the harbor or maybe a curious manatee. If you will be sitting outside don't forget some bug spray. This is a BYOB restaurant.  


Small Title

Mango's Cafe & Grille

Outdoor & Fine Cocktails

This is a very popular spot on the weekends and can get crowded. It is a great place for cocktails with friends. On busy weekends the atmosphere at the outdoor bar can get a bit wild. We don't recommend this restaurant for children during those busy times. 


Keep in mind that many of the restaurants on the island close early due to the staff having to take a ferry back home. . 

bottom of page